How the Odds are Stacked Against our Children
- Sarah Thiel

- Aug 21
- 6 min read
We know which populations throughout the world provide excellent examples of longevity and health, but there are several reasons why many Americans simply cannot adopt similar diets and lifestyles to these so-called "Blue Zones"... here are some key barriers:
US Government Food Policies
The federal government provides billions of dollars in subsidies to farmers who grow certain commodity crops, especially:
Corn
Soybeans
Wheat
Rice
Cotton
These crops are not primarily grown for direct human consumption in their raw forms but are used to produce processed ingredients, such as:
High-fructose corn syrup (from corn)
Vegetable oils (from soybeans)
Refined flour (from wheat)
Animal feed (for factory-farmed meat and dairy)
As a result, foods that contain these heavily subsidized ingredients—such as soda, chips, fast food, and processed snacks—end up being cheaper to produce and purchase than whole fruits, nuts, seeds, beans, and vegetables.
Lack of Subsidies for Whole Foods
Fruits, vegetables, nuts, and legumes—often called "specialty crops"—receive far fewer subsidies. In fact, only a small fraction of federal farm support goes to these foods.
This imbalance:
Disincentivizes farmers from growing fruits and vegetables
Makes fresh, healthy food more expensive
Leads to a market flooded with cheap processed options
Support for Industrial Agriculture
Government policy has long favored large-scale, industrial farming:
These operations benefit from economies of scale, further lowering the price of processed ingredients.
Smaller, diversified, organic, or regenerative farms—which are more likely to grow healthier foods—face higher production costs with less government support.
Food Assistance Programs & Industry Influence
Programs like SNAP (food stamps) allow purchasing of nearly all food products, including ultra-processed foods. While this supports food access, critics argue it can unintentionally:
Encourage consumption of cheap, unhealthy foods
Bolster demand for subsidized, processed items
Additionally, food industry lobbying has historically influenced dietary guidelines, labeling policies, and subsidies, often prioritizing corporate profit over public health.
Cultural Norms & Food Preferences
Dietary Habits: In the U.S., food culture is heavily centered around convenience, fast food, and meat-heavy diets (especially beef, chicken, and processed foods). This is quite different from the more plant-centric and simple diets seen in Blue Zones, where meals tend to be whole-food-based, with much more emphasis on vegetables, legumes, and whole grains.
Taste Preferences: American food culture tends to favor rich, calorie-dense meals, often laden with fats, sugars, and processed ingredients, which are more immediately satisfying in terms of taste. A Mediterranean or Okinawan-style meal may not be as instantaneously appealing for someone accustomed to high-fat or fast food options.
Economic Factors
Access to Healthy Food: Many low-income areas (especially in urban environments) lack access to fresh food markets or grocery stores that sell nutritious options. These areas are often called food deserts, where the only easily accessible options are fast food chains or convenience stores.
Convenience & Time
Busy Lifestyles: The average American's lifestyle is fast-paced and often revolves around long work hours and commuting, making it difficult to prepare meals that require more time or effort. The Blue Zones, on the other hand, tend to have a slower pace of life, with time spent cooking, socializing, and enjoying family meals.
Fast Food & Pre-Packaged Meals: For many Americans, fast food and pre-packaged meals provide a quick fix that fits into their hectic schedules. The preparation of whole foods or plant-based meals often takes more time and planning.
Dieting & Weight Loss Trends
Protein-Heavy Focus: There's a cultural obsession in the U.S. with high-protein diets, especially in fitness and bodybuilding circles. The Blue Zones, by contrast, often have moderate protein intake, with an emphasis on plant-based sources, and not the large amounts of animal and whey protein that dominate SAD (Standard American Diets).
Diet Fads: Many Americans focus on short-term diets and weight loss programs (like keto, paleo, or intermittent fasting) rather than long-term sustainable lifestyle changes. While these diets can have health benefits in the short term, they are not shown to promote the overall wellness and longevity associated with Blue Zone diets, which focus on balanced, whole-food nutrition and moderation.
Lack of Education
Nutritional Knowledge: While awareness of health and nutrition is growing in the U.S., many people still have limited knowledge about the long-term benefits of a plant-based, whole food diet. In contrast, Blue Zone communities have a tradition of home cooking, with older generations teaching younger ones how to prepare nourishing, wholesome meals.
Marketing & Misleading Information: The food industry, especially companies producing processed and fast food, invests billions in advertising and marketing products that are often not the healthiest options. This creates confusion about what constitutes a healthy diet and promotes processed foods that are cheaper and more convenient than the plant-based options seen in Blue Zones.
Social & Environmental Factors
Social Norms: In many American communities, eating out or ordering takeout is a social activity, and food often plays a central role in celebrations and gatherings. These communal eating habits tend to revolve around large portions, meat-heavy meals, and sugary treats.
Environmental Pressures: In the Blue Zones, communities emphasize the importance of socializing, walking, and spending time outdoors. In contrast, American life is often dominated by sedentary behavior, high-stress levels, and a reliance on cars.
Food Industry Influence
Processed Food Industry: The U.S. is home to a massive processed food industry that influences much of the country's food landscape. Foods that are quick, cheap, and easy to produce (like snacks, sodas, fast food, and instant meals) dominate the marketplace. This makes it challenging for more whole-food-based diets to take precedence.
Portion Sizes: To get the same number of micronutrients, American portions must be higher in calories than those in Blue Zones. This is due to the much lower nutrient density of SAD.
Lack of Holistic Focus
Focus on Longevity: In Blue Zones, people tend to focus on living well rather than just on dieting or losing weight. The idea is that a healthy diet, physical activity, stress reduction, and strong social connections together contribute to longevity. In contrast, many Americans are primarily focused on immediate results, whether it's weight loss or muscle gain, without considering the holistic approach to health and wellness that should be emphasized.
Summary: Why Don't More Americans Have Healthy Lifestyles?
Food policy: millions of Americans (not to mention schools and other institutions) simply cannot afford fresh fruits, vegetables, nuts, and legumes, aka "specialty crops"—which receive far fewer subsidies than the billions of dollars the federal government provides to farmers who grow commodity crops.
Cultural preferences and food habits: The American diet is centered on fast, processed, and calorie-dense foods.
Economic factors: Many low-income areas (especially in urban environments) lack access to fresh food markets or grocery stores that sell nutritious options.
Convenience: Time and busy lifestyles make quick, processed foods more attractive.
Lack of awareness: Many people aren’t fully aware of the benefits of a plant-first, meat-second, whole-food diet.
Food industry influence: Marketing and portion sizes from the processed food industry promote unhealthy eating patterns.
Holistic approach to life: Blue Zones focus on a balanced lifestyle, including nutrition, physical activity, and strong social ties, rather than just diet alone.
Moving Toward a Healthier Diet:
While it may be challenging for many Americans to adopt a full Blue Zone lifestyle, there are simple steps you can take to start living better:
Support and vote for representatives who take initiative against current food policies and subsidies.
Increase plant-based foods: Add more vegetables, legumes, and whole grains to your diet.
Eat mindfully: Practice eating smaller portions and stopping when you're 80% full.
Focus on quality, not quantity: Choose whole, unprocessed foods over fast food or packaged options.
Get moving: Incorporate more walking and physical activity into daily life.
Foster community: Spend time with friends and family, and prioritize social connections
This was written in hopes that we can help at least one person live a longer, healthier, happier life. Please share your success story with us, as we would love knowing we made an impact!
Live long and strong,
Sarah and Calvin











Comments